Comodo Internet Security 4 Beta Review - Free Security At Its Best

Written by:  • Edited by: Michele McDonough
Published Jan 16, 2010
• Related Guides: Windows 7 | Comodo
4

The long awaited Comodo Internet Security 4 was recently released to the public in beta form. Is it as good as its award-winning precedent? Has this version sacrificed security for user-friendliness?

Introduction

Security enthusiasts might have heard of Comodo Internet Security v. 3. It is a free security suite, mostly aimed for knowledgable users. But the "newbies" are left confused by some of its alerts..."'svchost.exe" is trying to connect to 192.168.1.1! What does this mean?"

Comodo promised that version 4 would be friendlier for the newbies too. Some others have raised a question: "Is CIS 4 still as secure as version 3?"

Let's take a look.

Installation
Rating Average

After downloading Comodo Internet Security 4 Beta, I booted up my Windows 7 virtual machine and executed the file. (The virtual machine system was a fresh install, except that Comodo Time Machine was installed beforehand. CIS and CTM work together when both installed.)

Beta Notice In this first screen, the CIS installer is telling us this is a beta. For those who don't know what a beta is, click here. Basically, we shouldn't install this yet on our regular computers, because it is still new and "buggy." If you are unlucky, bad things could happen...so always use an alternate computer or a virtual machine to test betas.

Destination This shows were we want to have the CIS files go. Usually I don't mess with this (you don't need to).

Email Subscription If you want to receive Comodo's newletter, put in your email address.

Product Selection In CIS, there are three main components: the antivirus (AV), the firewall, and Defense+ (D+ is a HIPS: a boiled down description is that it alerts you to changes programs are making on your computer). You can choose whether or not to install the AV or firewall. I'm installing both.

ThreatCast If you joined ThreatCast, in an alert you will see what other users have done. The popular choice isn't always right, but it can help.

DNS Comodo offers its own DNS service. I'll keep with the default and not use it.

Installing Finally CIS is installing. I don't particularly like CIS's installers—they have too many screens and options. At least you aren't tricked into getting anything non-security related, though.

After being installed, a restart is needed.

8 Restart Needed 

Look and Feel
Rating Good

Some CIS users said the GUI (graphical user interface) of v. 3 wasn't newbie-friendly, while others liked it. The GUI in version 4 is only slightly changed, with a new red look.

Main Screen You may notice that it is saying Comodo Application Agent is not running. I'm not sure what this does and what it will affect, but since this machine is clean except for Comodo Time Machine I was a bit surprised. However, it is a beta and unstable.

Please see the next page for more features and the rest of this review on Comodo Internet Security 4.

Showing page 1 of 2

Comments

Showing all 4 comments
 
Jeremy Bost Apr 5, 2010 9:41 PM
Re: vendor "white list" defeats comodo firewall.
Please don't spread lies like this.

First, that Trust Vendor List is not new. It has been there for quite a few major releases.

Since only trusted vendors are included, there isn't much risk of any malicious activity.

And, you got another point wrong: I'm 99% sure that the List only applies to Defense+, the HIPS. After all, since Microsoft is on the list, I don't get D+ alerts. But I do get firewall alerts for Microsoft programs. So, you are quite wrong about it allowing them to the internet.

And the final point: you can decide not to use the trusted vendors. Just check the D+ settings....
(and you can delete trusted vendors too)

"This release isn't a secure firewall, it is a back door for corporate America to enter your pc without your knowledge and without your being able to do anything about it."

Hilarious. First, I doubt anything bad would happen even IF "corporate America" "entered" your PC. If they did anything, they would most likely be caught. There are many ways to see what some program is doing. And that isn't possible without triggering a firewall alert, which doesn't rely on the Trusted Vendor list.

Besides, you should research before installing a program.

Jeremy
mang Apr 5, 2010 9:16 PM
vendor "white list" defeats comodo firewall.
Comodo has added a "trusted vendor white list" to their latest release which allows "trusted vendors" programs to circumvent the firewall and access the internet no matter how hard you try to stop them...effectively defeating the purpose of their firewall by allowing all "trusted" (by Comodo, NOT ME!!!!) vendors to access the Internet unhindered.

This release isn't a secure firewall, it is a back door for corporate America to enter your pc without your knowledge and without your being able to do anything about it.
Jeremy Bost Jan 30, 2010 11:39 AM
Sandbox
I think it is for 64 bit too...but CIS4's "sandbox" is still a bit new and different from sandboxie.
RUSI Jan 30, 2010 11:32 AM
If they could make sandboxie for the 64 bit (windows 7) it would be super!
If they could make sandboxie for the 64 bit (windows 7) it would be super!
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend