Free Antivirus Shootout: AVG vs AntiVir vs Avast! – Part 1

Article by Donna Buenaventura (8,660 pts ) , published May 29, 2009

Which is the best free antivirus software? This article compares 3 of the most widely used solutions: AVG, AntiVir and Avast!

Avast, AVG and AntiVir are the widely-used free antivirus programs on the market, but testing each in order to decide which you should use can be a time consuming process. So, I've done all the hard work for you. Read on to find out whether AVG, Avast! or AntiVir is the best choice for your PC.

Best Antivirus Installer: Avast

Installing AVG can confuse some people. The installer bundles a third party toolbar that is not required in order to be able to use the program. Opting to not install the AVG Security Toolbar during installation will not remove any of AVG's security features. The AVG Safe Surf and AVG Safe Search (aka LinkScanner) will still be installed even if you do not install AVG Security Toolbar. However if you do not want LinkScanner feature in AVG, you will need to use the custom installation instead of the standard method. After installing AVG, the program will display a nag that you can hide every time you open the program.

Like AVG, AntiVir will nag you by showing a pop-up window during updates. However, AntiVir’s installer is not bundled with third party software and will not confuse you during installation. Neither AVG nor AntiVir require a system restart before the program can be used.

Avast has a better installer than AVG and AntiVir because it does not nag and does not have bundled software. It requires a system restart though before you can start using the program.

The AVG and AntiVir installers do not require you to enter an e-mail address for they will automatically generate a license key. Avast on the other hand requires registration in order for you to receive the free product key via e-mail.

User Interface: AntiVir and AVG

Most people want programs that are easy to navigate and some people want programs that look good. Avast's user interface is like a media player, and might not appeal some of you (it's one of those love it or hate it things!). Additionally, the program's options are scattered around and it's not always easy to find what you're looking for.

AVG’s UI is nicer than Avast's, allowing you to manage the program’s settings without confusion. But I find AntiVir to have better UI than either Avast or AVG because it’s staightforward  and Windows Security Center in Vista or XP. The resident shield of AVG is often reporting its status as turn-off which triggers Windows Security Center in displaying a balloon and changed AVG icon by showing status alert of the resident antivirus protection.

Comments

Oct 29, 2009 5:41 PM
RE: Free Antivirus Shootout: AVG vs AntiVir vs Avast! – Part 1
Hi Mike,
None of the above programs consumed a lot of resources during a scan and/or while it is monitoring the system (when I tested). That can change though if the vendors will push a program update that will cause 90% to 100% of resources due to bug but they usually release a fix, if reported or many is impacted.

Hope this helps.
Oct 29, 2009 4:23 PM
Mike Frizzi
another important feature
First off, good job on this comparison. I especially like the mention of the little 'nag' that comes up with the two

Antivirus
programs...I cannot stand those things. One element that really factors into my decision is, unfortunately, one that you left out. Namely: How much of a footprint do they leave on your system? I mean RAM usage, CPU usage, overall install sizes, etc..

I read the whole article and just wanted to comment again. Most of my concerns were addressed. One more thing, have you seen any of these programs run away with resources..as in, just eat them up until they are consuming all the RAM. I am determined to avoid all of those AV programs moving forward.
Oct 29, 2009 1:28 PM
Mike Frizzi
An important feature...
First off, good job on this comparison. I especially like the mention of the little 'nag' that comes up with the two <ahref="http://www.sophos.com">Antivirus</a> programs...I cannot stand those things. One element that really factors into my decision is, unfortunately, one that you left out. Namely: How much of a footprint do they leave on your system? I mean RAM usage, CPU usage, overall install sizes, etc..

edit: Just saw part 2...Excellent!
Jul 24, 2009 11:01 AM
PAOLO
AVAST ANTIVIRUS
I WOULD HAVE IF IT IS POSSIBLE NEW UNICODE FOR AVAST ANTIVIRUS
 
Subscribe to Computer Security
RSS
Get free weekly updates, directly to your inbox.
Browse Computer Security