The iPad - 2010's First Failure?

Written by:  • Edited by: J. F. Amprimoz
Updated May 9, 2010
• Related Guides: Adobe | iPhone | Apple

Inside, we look at why you should avoid the iPad like the plague. You'll find a few reasons why it can't compare to the competition and a bit of opinion as to why the device was made in the first place.

The High Road Is Hard to Find

This week’s unveiling of the iPad brought along with it a lot of people apologizing for its faults out of sheer fondness for Apple. The iPad is a colossal misstep for a company that’s more calculated about its moves than a man sweeping a minefield. This is the company that brought us the iPhone just to bring us the completely underwhelming iPad three years later? Let’s boil this failure down to a few key points.

Where Does it Fit?

The iPad (in addition to the widespread and instant derision it has received for having a name reminiscent of a feminine hygene product) currently exists in gadget purgatory. It is not functional enough to replace a netbook, or small enough to replace a smart phone. It is, as it stands, a confusingly useless device for the average consumer. If you have a PC/Mac/Laptop and a phone, why buy this mutant that underwhelms on both sides?

Features List?

I want to hammer this point home in this article. If you walk away with nothing else, just remember this. A cell phone or mobile PC that’s incapable of handling Adobe’s Flash standard in the year 2010 is nothing short of inexcusable. Sure, you can feed me a PR-ready line about HTML5 and Apple’s long-fought cases against Adobe for being a monopoly on the market, but the fact remains, the web breathes in Flash and if your new device doesn’t support it, you can’t quite claim that it allows you to “see the internet better than ever before”.

Also, I will disregard the lack of expandable memory, expandable RAM, multi-SIM card slots, USB slots, and even the fact that the native resolution is an odd one for a device of this size, as well as the lack of HDMI. But one thing that should also stand out to you is the lack of multitasking. The iPad can’t do what a Windows 95 PC or an Apple PC from the 90s could – which is run two programs simultaneously side-by-side. I may have become spoiled with Windows 7, but I’d like to think that my “laptop substitute” should be able to run more than one program at a time.

Some Final Thoughts

Listen, I’m not here to rag on Apple. I love my iPhone (although I’d give it up in a heartbeat for a Zune HD phone with OLED and 720p video) and it suits my life perfectly, but the iPad is a useless invention that may one day become great if given the right kind of treatment. As it currently stands, it’s the perfect device for my generation (people in their 20s), a generation often referred to as a “generation of wants over needs”. Nobody needs an iPad, there isn’t even a good justification for why the product is on the market. But as long as my generation continues to swallow PR garbage and buy these products, this is what will continue to happen. 3 years after a revolutionary device comes out, companies will be content to sit on their laurels, waiting for your hard-earned cash to be dropped into their massive wallets as they churn out yet another iPad or another iteration of a device nobody needs.


Comments

Showing all 10 comments
 
James Apr 6, 2010 6:45 PM
The iPad will not fail
The iPad will not fail for some of the reasons you think it might. It is a device of want, and want drives buying more than need does. My full commments at
http://yaiknow.com/the-ipad-will-not-fail/
Sam Mar 12, 2010 8:54 PM
Lol
Loling at all the Apple fanboys responding to this article. Face the fact that Apple has failed. No matter how good their past products have been (I personally don't think much of them, though I own none), they have always been roughly 2x the cost of PC products. Now, they combine fail with high price. And I'm sure you all know that fail + high price = EPIC FAIL.
John Mar 9, 2010 10:13 AM
re:ipad
@Chris, the only reason why apple doesn't have viruses is because its not worth taking the time to get such a small amount of people, unlike if they make a pc virus so many people will be effected its worth it, Anyways all you need is an anti virus which is only like 20-30$ a year. Lets say your computer lasts 10 years thats only 200-300 more which is still alot less then any apple products with the same quality. your a retard btw.
^_^-^ Feb 16, 2010 5:00 PM
RE: The iPad - 2010's First Failure?
You're clearly a PC fanboy, who the hell would want a zune over an iphone? Maybe you should wait till you have tried the ipad >.>
Chris Feb 5, 2010 11:55 PM
ipad
Stop! the blood clot cryin'. buy one or try it out before you start to bash apple for a product "they felt was necessary". Also, no one talked about viruses vs the vulnerable pc? nuff said!
wonderwhy-er Feb 4, 2010 5:40 AM
iPad
@john sargent
Well what you see is a pre-sales market response.
For many it is "WoW" factor that will make them buy one just because they can.

Then there are Apple fanboys that will buy it too.

Then there are those who needed a PC in this form factor and not a iPod/hand-held console like device. Yay for Windows 7 based alternatives.
Michael Feb 3, 2010 8:49 AM
iPad
I agree to some extent that it is a 'want' more than a 'need'. However, in a household where 4 of us compete to get on the iMac it will allow access to most of what we use it for (web!) for just $499. And from anywhere in the house.
I would disagree with Flash being essential. It appears on 1 out of 50 sites I would use and more often than not for annoying 'disco' advertising! I think we'll see the death of it before too long.
J.J Feb 2, 2010 2:39 AM
RE: The iPad - 2010's First Failure?
iPad at first is a product with a WOW factor to me.. i mean.. despite it 100% is just a scaled up iPod touch, its still sleek and seems to be a nice gadget to have.. thats until i saw the specs...

i would be supportive and would even wanted the iPad if it satisfy these conditions:

1. SD slot for expansion, as a mobile gadget this is a must for me!
2. cut all the iPod crap! let me load music in mp3 without iTunes!
3. if u sell it as media gadget then be more open on media formats! finding or converting iPod compatible video is annoying to me.. just let me copy the damn avi and mkv already...
4. not iPhone OS!!! i want a tablet not oversized mp3 player with games..
5. freedom to install computer programs.. which by using iPhone os is a definete impossible..
6. maybe Flash is no longer the big thing.. but it still dominant in the net so currently this Apple's "internet gadget" is like offering a browser that only render texts..

its a very huge shame for apple to conceive such device with lack of what many ppl expect much.. it looked like i put too much faith on apple this time cause they seems to still drowned in the "multi-touch" success and forget everything else :(

at least.. perhaps if Apple was kind enough to create a satellite transceiver module and some navigation apps it may look cool enough as your car GPS lol... but for work or even my entertainment, using it would be complicated pain in my own ass..
Daniel Barros Feb 1, 2010 4:07 PM
RE: The iPad - 2010's First Failure?
Flash might not be a big deal in about 5 years or so, but at least for the immediate future, not having Flash is purely a marketing thing for Apple. They want you to buy their highly marked up apps from their app store and not contend with the competition that free flash sites offer. Also, no Hulu, so you can keep buying TV and movies off of their iTunes store.

I understand your point, but I think the market has already spoken by collectively issuing a "meh" to this device before it has even shipped.
john sargent Feb 1, 2010 2:08 PM
Ipad
U rush to judgement, there r a growing number who are tired of Adobe, so no flash is not a big deal, why not let the market make a judgemnt or are u the only smart knife in the drawer, lets wait for 90 days after shipping, see who is buying and who isn't, and why, the buyers will vote , you talking heads wont.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend