Stargate Resistance - PC Game Review

Written by:  • Edited by: M.S. Smith
Published Feb 21, 2010
• Related Guides: iPhone | Playstation 1 | Windows
2

A review of the new PC game called Stargate Resistance, which is a shooter based on the Stargate series.

Stargate Resistance

Stargate Resistance No matter how much you love the Stargate series, you should absolutely stay the hell away from Stargate Resistance. Before it was even released to Steam, the company behind it had already filed for bankruptcy. This is an online-only game that requires a painful install/login process, and the game itself is clearly just a scrapped together effort for the company to recover some of the funds spent on their vaporware Stargate MMO. Do not waste your money on this game.

Gameplay
Rating Average

stargate1 Stargate Resistance is a third person shooter set in the Stargate universe. It features six soldier classes (3 SGC and 3 System Lords) and you can only play in three maps. The maps aren’t very big, either. You have game types like team deathmatch and capture the flag which are staples of shooters, so there isn’t anything new to this game. Basically, you just pick a class and run around shooting each other. A variety of weapons does help to make things a little more interesting, but overall it’s just a run-and-gun type game that requires very little in the way of tactics or strategy.

Graphics
Rating Average

The levels are pretty nicely designed and there are tons of hiding places and limited access areas for sniping, so there is some good potential there as far as the level designs. The problem is that the game does not run very smoothly. It’s not a graphic card issue, but mainly just clunky programming. My system can play Left 4 Dead and Crysis without a hiccup, but in this game it seems jerky.

While running through the three measly levels in this game, I was impressed by the textures. This game was made using the Unreal 3 engine, so it looks quite good in some places. Unfortunately, the character models are garbage and your own character looks like something out of a PlayStation 1 game. I’m not kidding. The whole package here looks like a game better suited for the PS2 or some system from yesteryear. By today’s standards, most people are going to be turned off by the graphics. The screenshots (see below) are very misleading because they do not depict the actual gameplay.

Screenshots

Stargate ResistanceStargate ResistanceStargate ResistanceStargate ResistanceStargate Resistance

Sound
Rating Poor

While playing this game, I could hear faint sound effects and music. It was like the sound effects just didn’t work right. I discovered that the game is incompatible with surround sound right now, so you will have to change your audio settings (in Windows) to stereo sound in order to hear the effects in this game. You know what? I’m not going to do that. I am not going to change a system-wide setting in order to make one game work because I’d have to go change it back for every other game I play. Forget that!

Overall
Rating Below Average

I tried to like this game. I really did. I was sympathetic to the indie software market and all that, and I understand the people behind this were just trying to get something from their efforts with the doomed Stargate MMO. I’ve read some message board comments where people talk about the economy and all that. I get it – times are tough. Cheyenne Mountain Entertainment declared bankruptcy before this game even became available to download from Steam.

However, on the other end of that argument is the consumer. I was not given a free copy of this game to review. I saw it and was so interested that I spent my own money to purchase the game. Now I can’t help but feel like I wasted twenty bucks on something that is just a scrapped-together underwhelming third person shooter. This game might have worked as a 99 cent iPhone shooter, but for a PC game it just isn’t acceptable to charge that much for so little. In many ways, this game is just a demo for what the Stargate MMO could have been.

For more information on this game, visit StargateResistance.com.

To see what many people are saying about this game, visit the Steam forums.


Comments

Showing all 3 comments
 
dubbed Apr 24, 2010 9:41 PM
Outdated characters
The reason the models look so poor is because they are imported straight from the stargate worlds game (an mmo). Which uses lower poly characters, CME trying to rush a product to bring in some money.
Raistlin Mar 13, 2010 3:34 PM
what?
(I'll wait a good 6 months b4 I expect something better, like with a few patches or expansions.)

I'm sorry didn't you read what was said above? The company that made this had declared bankruptcy, that means no money, no workers, no product, and if another company does happen to buy there product rights I doubt there going to even touch resistance.
I have watched stargate from the first year and love it but when I saw this game my "scam sense began to tingle" even the website look like something from 6 years ago. What the company "or one of the many laid off programers should do" is realease the code that would hopefully make it moddable, with that the fans themselves would would make it a game worthy of stargate.
John Feb 23, 2010 9:39 PM
Graphics
I think the game is all around good for 20 bucks. Somewhere I heard that the development time was only 6 or 8 months. If thats the case, then man, the levels are pretty dang good. Yea the characters could be better, don't know if they hashed the models from Stargate Worlds, if they did then that would explain it.
The graphic rating doesn't deserve a three, I worked on RE4 and I have to say these graphics are really nice for what your paying for. I would rate it a 4 out of 5. There are places that could look better, but again if the dev time was what I'm hearing, then great job.
I don't know why people think SGW looks better, these graphics are far more superior.
The gameplay is what it is. I'll wait a good 6 months b4 I expect something better, like with a few patches or expansions. Then I will make my final decision if I want to keep supporting this thing.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend