Tales of Monkey Island: Launch of the Screaming Narwhal does an adequate job of keeping you interested by telling a mystery story, focusing on the situations surrounding Guybrush's cursed hand, the reasons behind the terrible winds on Flotsam Island, and the secrets that are hidden there. You can choose different dialogues from characters you meet who will provide you with clues and info about those mysteries. They do have a lot to say, and thankfully the conversations have spark and personality to them.
The game could have used more characters since there are only a limited number of residents to talk to on Flotsam Island. Don't expect a long game. Tales of Monkey Island: Launch of the Screaming Narwhal feels more like a prologue to hopefully more epic stories in the future episodes.
The best parts of the story belong to the characters, specifically Guybrush, the Voodoo Lady, the doctor, and the glass blower. They all have funny and witty dialogue to share. A few characters like to poke fun at Guybrush while Guybrush likes to make tongue-in-cheek remarks on items he finds and objects he examines. Pirates are known for being tough as nails, but in this game you won't find many who fit that picture. Since they can't leave the island because of the winds, a few manage to keep themselves busy with interesting jobs and hobbies you don't expect to see in a pirate. One of them is D'oro, a jolly fat pirate who enjoys collecting and playing with action figures.
The comedy is well written and it really helps to bring the story to life.