Well, if you are Min/Maxing and looking for the one with the best numbers, Phoebe starts the game with 10 grand and a good fleet, and Asterion only gets 5 grand, but is the only hero to get three boats early. Those are your best choices. Petrakles only gets 7 grand, though he gets a Unireme, which is more than you can say for Theophilos. He’s got cash and a good starting location, but the worst fleet.
That is somewhat balanced by the usefulness of the special abilities. Stopping enemy attacks and dealing damage to the enemy, which Theophilos and Petrakles, respectively, can do, are always useful. Asterion and Phoebe’s skills only help if you have a fleet set up for ramming or for ranged combat, respectively.
The main thing is, the difference in game play isn’t that dramatic. A half hour into the game, you will have enough money and ships that the starting cash and fleet is pretty irrelevant. The most noticeable, both immediate and long term, impact of your decision will be in the quest lines specific to the character and their dialogue.
They are all very funny, but you will laugh hardest if you choose the character you’re fondest of or find most amusing. I picked Theophilos for this reason, and now that I have given all four a whirl, and found his starting fleet to be the worst, he is still my favourite.
Once you’ve decided on your alter-ego, you’re thrown into the game. It’s a big game with a lot to do though, so the first steps can be a little daunting. That’s why we put together a getting started guide for Tradewinds Odyssey.