Released in 1995, Stars! seemed purpose built for cult-classic status. Its graphics worked well in 1995, and work well today, largely because there aren't any. Ships are represented by arrows, sensors range is represented by colored circles, and planets are small dots. Pretty it isn't, but much like Civilizations II, it isn't ugly, either. Stars! is a 4x strategy that acknowledges that at its core, many of these games are all about economic strategy. Sure, it often looks like a spreadsheet - but you'll also know what is going on.
Strangely, despite its simplistic graphics, Stars! is likely one of the most epic strategy games ever made. As games progress, the amount of industrial power available starts to become extremely high. As a result, players gain the ability to create fleets with thousands of ships, resulting in battles that - at least in your imagination - look a bit like a re-enactment of The Battle Of Endor.
Players who are into customization will also fall in love with this game. Stars! includes numerous ship hulls, each of which can be customized with a plethora of sensors, weapons, and armors, resulting in truly personalized ships. The race maker is also complex and fun, allowing the player to choose from massive list of racial traits, as well as customize what kind of planetary conditions their race will be able to tolerate.
Note that Stars! is abandoned at this point, so don't expect to find it for sale. You'll have to go to Stars! fansites to find a copy of it.