
click to enlarge
This raises an interesting issue about the purpose of Beta testing. Closed Beta tests are less common than they used to be and this is partly because news is often leaked. For an
MMO game early bad word of mouth can be disastrous. Open Beta used to be about perfecting the gameplay and even fixing late bugs but it seems that today it is more about marketing the game and building an audience before the proper release. Games need decent
subscriber populations in order to succeed.
When you ask fans to beta test a game for free your expectations have to be limited. Some of them are wonderful and identify bugs with detailed steps for reproduction or suggest excellent tweaks to the gameplay or rules while others are virtually useless. Online Beta tests can be very useful but they are no replacement for an experienced QA department. With the potential backlash from a bad Beta test the fear is that the game could sink because of it, even if subsequent changes are made. This is a sad state of affairs, the original purpose of the Beta test is completely lost if this is the case. Instead of garnering useful feedback for last minute tweaks it becomes an early demo.