Paying Employees on Commission

Written by:  • Edited by: Michele McDonough
Updated May 19, 2011

Does you business call for paying employees on commission? If so, what sales commission plan should you use? Jean Scheid takes a look at sales commission pay plans and how they work.

Developing Sales Commission Plans

Toontown Planning Commission by Han Shot First
click to enlarge

Are you in the sales business? Do you plan to pay your employees commission? Is one sales commission plan better than another? These are all good questions and finding the right commission plan is essential in keeping your employees happy and long-term.

Commission pay plans are usually based on two factors, employee performance, and a percentage of what they have sold. It is possible to over-reward and pay out a percentage that is too high so what are the best sales commission pay plans?

When developing a commission-based pay plan, think of these factors:

  • It should be simple - If your commission plan has so many tiers to achieve and wording your sales team doesn't understand, it's useless to the employee.
  • Goals - Are the goals you set unreachable? If they are, re-look at these goals.
  • Focus with teams - Decide if team focus is better than individual. This doesn't work for all commission-based pay plans, but works well in a tight sales competitive businesses like car sales.
  • It should be flexible - Never try and keep the same plan year after year, or even month after month. If sales people or teams are achieving goals time after time, they are making your business money so you can change the commission pay plan to reflect that.

Now that you know what key items should be part of your commission pay plan, which plan is best?

Decide on Your Commission Pay Plan

Commission pay plans are usually structured in one of the following ways:

  1. Low Commission and High Salary - This type of commission plan is effective for in-house sale personnel, or people who make cold contacts. Offering a higher salary so they can actually make a living and a low commission on cold calls that turn into sales is often preferable for cold-calling in-house sales. See this article for more on sales bonus programs of this type.
  2. Sales by Individuals - Simply put, sales people who sell from walk-ins at the company, pull in customers and focus on the sale itself should be paid a percentage of each sale.
  3. Territorial Sales - If you have a company that sends your sales people to assigned territories, base your commission plan on volume in each territory. If you try this, make sure you understand who your customers are and don't send your sales team to areas where competitors rule.
  4. Sharing in the Profits - This type of commission pay plan works well with sales managers. Skip individual sales commissions and pay them on the bottom line profits each month. Effective sales managers will do well with this plan if they are good at motivating and training their sales teams.
  5. Hitting the Mark - Some commission pay plans are goal oriented. You may decide that if a sales person sells up to five products they get a certain percentage, a higher percentage will apply if ten products are sold. An even higher percentage will be the option if they hit twenty products sold and so on.

As the business owner, you will need to decide which type of pay plan works best for your type of business. Talk to other business owners who pay on commission and ask what types of plans work for them. Ask your sales team for input on what types of plans they think will work best for their lifestyle.

Common Commission Pay Plan Rules

Every business owner who utilizes a commission-based pay plan will need to consider these rules:

  • Slow months - Even if your team or sales person is the best there is, you will have slow months. Keep in mind that it is impossible for your employees to live without money, so offer draws on their commissions during slow months. Draws are dollars given to your sales team and are not taxed. When they do receive their next commission pay check, the draw is taxed along with their commission and then the draw is taken out of their net pay.
  • Keep promises - No matter what types of commission pay plan you decide upon, keep your promise or you will lose good employees. Retail sales jobs are easy to get and you want to retain your best employees.
  • Offer benefits - Even if you can't afford health care in today's economy, offer other benefits, like company cars, gasoline allowances, and retirement plans. If you can, do offer health care that is affordable to your sales personnel and the company.
  • Employee advances - Try to avoid this and go the draw route instead. It's amazing how employee advances can accrue and if you do it for one employee, others will expect the same.
  • Keep it in writing - No matter what commission pay plan you utilize, put it in writing and have the employee sign it.

Your best bet if you plan to pay your employees on commissions is to network with business owners who do the same. Often, other business owners may have ideas you haven't thought of that will work best for your company. Do some research and get employee input. Next combine your research with employee input to develop the best plan. Remember, commission pay plans can always be re-evaluated and changed to benefit both the employee and your business.


Comments

Showing all 22 comments
 
Asher Jembo Jan 13, 2012 8:07 AM
RE: Paying Employees on Commission
Taxation for employees on commission basis; How does work?
Jean Scheid Aug 24, 2011 9:38 PM
To James
I would ask your sales personnel which they prefer, the entire commission or a monthly-based commission--either is fine.
Jean
James Aug 24, 2011 2:48 PM
Commission on monthly payments
We have a small business that offers internet advertising to local businesses. Up until now we have only been accepting single payments for yearly commissions.

We want to offer monthly payments, as a lot of small businesses are asking for this.

How do we pay commission on this? Do we pay their entire commission up front, or do we pay the commission as each monthly payment comes in?
Jean Scheid Jul 10, 2011 10:38 AM
To Sherri
Hi Sherri,
There are a couple ways you could do this. Some advertising sales reps receive a flat commission, say 15% on the sale and you can add the 15% to the cost of the advertisement. Another way would be to pay commissions on contract terms. For example, if a sales rep lands a business for one year, set a dollar amount the rep would receive and any ads the rep sells would still receive a commission % throughout the contract.
Good luck!
Jean
Sherri C Jul 9, 2011 2:38 AM
paying commission on re-occuring accounts
Hi, I am the owner of a publishing company and am wanting to contract out a Sales Account Rep and pay them straight commission. Since my clients are receiving a service, advertising, and paying me a monthly fee for this how am I supose to pay out commissions? Do they get commissions on the initial openning payment or do you typically pay monthly commissions for each month that the account remains active?
Sherri C Jul 9, 2011 2:10 AM
Pay-out for commision
I am the owner of a publishing company. I am wanting to contract out a sales rep to be paid strictly on commissions. Here is my question: Since the rep will be bringing in accounts that pay me monthly, am I suppose to pay commissions on the first month's income from the account or for each month that the account is active? I'm getting confused b/c I know if they were selling a product commission could be paid for that particular sell. With my business, they are paying for advertising on a monthly basis.
Any insight would be greatly appreciated.
~Sherri C
Jean Scheid Apr 13, 2011 5:18 PM
To JNirvaha
I have never head of any company that pays folks on sales commissions that doesn't offer forms or detail of sales and percentage of what the employee is actually being paid. I would check with your human resources department or your immediate supervisor and ask for commission payment detail.
Jean Scheid Apr 13, 2011 5:16 PM
To Gary
Hi Gary,
As far as salary plus commission and also charging desk rent, phone call usage, etc., you can do this, however, any rents or charges must be deducted from the commission itself, not as a deduction in the tax deduction section. I would check with your CPA, but since these deductions are prior to any other deductions, you may need to determine how these amounts appear on the employee's W-2 wage statements or 1099s.
Gary Apr 12, 2011 6:41 PM
salary + commission
Looking to pay my employees a salry + commission for buying and selling grain(wheat barley oats). I need come up with the salary less rent for the desk they sit at, phone they use to make long distance calls, cell phone, office space and possible other expences. Where should i start with the commission to pay 20% to start and work up to 25%.
Have you seen anything similar to this situation that i can use as a blue print.
JNirvaha Feb 21, 2011 4:02 PM
Sales Commission Reporting
Regardless of the plan, it is important the payment summary be clearly communicated. If I cant track where my money is coming from, how do I know I am receiving my full earnings?

Sales Commission
john Feb 10, 2011 2:00 PM
Commission and base salary
I think it would be great if the business owners leave that decision to the sales people. I am in a "100% commission based" company and we have a large turnover because of that strategy.

commission-statement
Jean Scheid Nov 23, 2010 8:37 PM
To Tad
Hi Tad,
I'm not sure if there are any state or federal laws that require employers to offer you a wash out sheet, but most sales commission-based industries do so salespeople can see what they earned on the gross or net. Perhaps it's something you can discuss with your HR department or owner to see if they can provide this via their payroll or accounting system.
Tad Nov 23, 2010 6:19 PM
Supporting documents
I work in a commission based industry, is there anything that mandates an employer to provide what I call a 'wash out' sheet? A document or spreadsheet that you get with every paycheck that outlines the 'deals' an employee got paid on during the pay period and the amount for each deal. I requested such a document for my own accounting purposes to make sure I get paid on deals at the amount I expected.
They just looked at me funny. I've received them before in a previous commission based job.

Working in Arizona
hfbadvertising Nov 10, 2010 9:50 AM
commission
What is a good price point for salary and commission base for our advertising design company. Is there different prices for 100% based commission vs salary + commission? Visit http://www.hfbadvertising.com for more info on what we do. Thanks
Jean Scheid Mar 17, 2010 1:49 PM
To DixieB
I would check first with the AZ Dept of Labor, however, the US Dept of Labor states salespeople who sell a product outside of a store or business (say if they have a district) are exempt from the minimum wage law. If you salesperson doesn't work or sell inside your place of business, you may be exempt from the miminum wage law. Further, this situation applies to you and your sales staff works off-site, write a sales commission agreement that clearly outlines how the sales people will be paid to avoid disputes. Remember, for commissions paid, if no taxes are taken out, you must issue a 1099 Income statement for each of your salespeople at year-end. Hope this helps.
Jean
DixieB Mar 17, 2010 11:25 AM
Paying by commission
I am starting a new business and wanted a sales person to work strictly on commission. I am not sure exactly what to pay or how to go about bonus's. This is a new product and I am the only distributor of this product in AZ. Can anyone help me?
Jean Scheid Feb 3, 2010 2:27 PM
To Connie
I would check with your Department of Labor first as every state may vary, however, I do believe that if an employee is at one location as their primary workplace and works the standard hours deemed by their Dept of Labor, they must paid minimum wage if their commission is lower. Hope this helps!
Jean
CONNIE Feb 3, 2010 1:10 PM
COMMSION VS MINIMUM WAGE
WHEN COMMSION IS LESS THEN MINIMUM WAGE FOR HOURS WORKED, IS IT LAW MINIMUM WAGE HAS TO BE PAID?
Jean Scheid Nov 11, 2009 2:49 PM
Banking Commission
Hi LF,
I have never set up a banked commission, however, I think it would be simple to do and allow both the employer and employee benefit.
As an employer, I would check with my local broker to ask about short-term investments where both the employer and employee funds could be invested (like a money-market account) and then disbursed in slow months. The employer may benefit most as he or she would receive the money-market interest unless an agreement could be reached on sharing in the interest. For those sales team members who are hard to sway into this type of program, it could even be voluntary. The broker or accountant could help you with tax issues.
Hope this helps!
Jean Scheid
LF Nov 11, 2009 2:03 PM
Bankable Commission Plan
JScied,

Excellent article, it is providing much needed information that supports what I have been saying for years to a non-sales boss. I have just one question. Have you heard of a commission plan that Banks the commission earned to balance out the sales commission paid during slow and high months?

I am trying to find information to battle my boss against this sort of idea but I need to understand it more and cannot find information on this. I have been very successful at creating and motivating my sales team however my boss is pressing me on this type of approach.

LF
Jean Scheid Sep 30, 2009 11:35 AM
Paid on Commission
Hello Linda,
You are what I would call "individual sales." 15% is a good commission for what you sell, however, I would ask about incentives (hitting sales goals), and find out if you 15% is on the gross sale or the net sale.
Hope this helps!
JScheid
linda alfiere Sep 30, 2009 11:27 AM
commission
Is 15% on every order I get to little. I am a shampoo sales person I work homebased for a shampoo pet co
only shampoo I feel my commission is low
Thank you
calfiere@cfl.rr.com
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend