Apple Aperture 3 Review

Written by:  • Edited by: Rhonda Callow
Updated May 20, 2011
• Related Guides: Facebook | Apple | Web Applications
4

Aperture 3 has over 200 new features including many new editing tools. Apple's Aperture 3 includes web tools to interface with Facebook and Flickr accounts. As would be expected, there are more tools and more interactivity between applications.

Aperture 3

Aperture3 Upgrade: $99.00

Full Version: $199.00

Compared to Apple Aperture 2, the latest version of the software, Aperture 3, has over 200 new features. Some welcome additions are the new custom editing tools, integration with other image applications and web syncing features. They have also added some interesting new fun features like the Faces feature that lets you organize your images by identifying individual faces. Overall, Aperture 3 has made significant improvements that enhance the usability of the product. Aperture 3 has added many new features that make editing for the consumer easier and more intuitive, but Apple has not addressed many issues relevant to the professional photographer.

Image Editing Tools
Rating Excellent

New in Aperture 3 are 39 new editing features and automations. Many of these are nice to have, but don't really impact basic editing needs.

The direct editing brushes are one of the best new features and they work great. These non-destructive brushes allow the photographer to make specific edits to sections of an image. Apple have added a whole new section of different brushes for skin softening, halo reduction, feathering and many others to experiment with. More advanced tools have been added to Aperture such as the Curves Tool, Highlight and Shadow and Edit with Plug-In Menu Item.

Many of Aperture's new tools are designed to help the user make edits and publish while staying in the edit mode. This saves time and steps in workflow. The Batch Apply Adjustments, Live Previews and Variable-Level Zoom are some of the new features that save time and make editing images more intuitive.

New Editing Features

Highlights and ShadowsNon-destructive Brushes and CurvesLive Preview

Faces and Places
Rating Average

Faces and Places move Aperture 3 more towards the consumer market than the professional photographer market. Faces let the user sort images by faces with new face recognition software. This application is suited for family albums and other non-production uses.

Places is a geographic locator application that shows where photos were taken using a GPS track log and then assigning photos to a particular location. Searches can be done by location and smart albums can be created that show only photos from a particular location. The Map + Photo View is interesting to see the map with the pictures and Google Maps has teamed up with Aperture so the user can see where they took their photos on a Google map displayed in Aperture.

Select Images by Face Recognition

FacesFace choices

Web Publishing
Rating Good

Images can now be published directly to Flickr or Facebook. The Faces feature can be used to publish particular images to Facebook. Publishing directly from the editor screen is a real time saver for those who use these sites. These are nice features for the consumer market, but not that important to professional photographers. It would have been nice to see some Web publishing tools for photo galleries or flash files that could be uploaded directly to a photographer's website.

These new features are rated good because they are nice features for consumers and they work seamlessly with the websites. The one knock here is that Aperture did not add more functions for Web applications

Video and Audio
Rating Average

Now that DSLRs come with mini video clip capability, it is nice to view those files in the same editor as the still images. This adds more functionality for users who use the video feature on their cameras. AIFF and MP3 are both supported and the audio track can be detached and saved as a stand-alone file. Aperture lets the user designate an external editing application, create a JPEG from a video frame, import audio attachments as well as other useful tools for audio/video editing. This is new for Aperture and is expected to improve in future upgrades.

Slideshow
Rating Below Average

The Slideshow function is just OK. Aperture gives you the ability to have a slide show. Of the eight-slideshow themes, none are that unique. Text can put on a slide, there are various simple transitions and audio can be put on the show. None of these is spectacular or innovative. The Slideshow function is accessed from the New menu on the Main Toolbar and appears to be more of an afterthought.

Slideshow TemplatePhotobook Template

Photobooks and Printing
Rating Average

These are lumped together because they are printing functions. Photobooks are great tools for the professional and gifts for the consumer. The layout is easy and has many options. Photos are easily inserted by using an import function or just drag and drop the picture into the desired location. Similarly, it is easy to edit these books and move photos around.

The print menu offers different print sizes and proof sheets. The menu is slim and offers little to the professional photographer. This is an area where Aperture can improve in the future.

Summary

Aperture 3 really beefed up the editing tools for more customizable images. The key wording and search options are greatly improved are easy to use. The look, menus and tool bar functions are improved and nicely designed. Apple has added many new features that work with new camera functions and Web applications. Overall, Aperture has made some nice upgrades, but many of the new features are designed for the consumer (or amateur photographer) more than the professional photographer.

This is great application for the consumer who does not want to pay the high-ticket price of Photoshop or take the time to learn the complex functions. Aperture 3 is easy to use, has a nice looking interface and works seamlessly with Web applications that are becoming increasingly more popular. It seems as if Apple has made a choice to move towards the amateur photographer market and leave the professional photographer market to Lightroom.


Comments

Showing all 5 comments
 
Caroline Thompson Feb 24, 2010 4:55 PM
Response to Al
Hi Al,

Actually, I gave the interface high marks for the consumer market. and for functionality. In fact, I talk about how seamlessly they work within the application. I think where people are confused with the review is that I separate the consumers from professionals. As a professional photographer, I don't use Facebook as a mainstay for moving images in and out of on a regular basis. On the other hand, many consumers use Facebook as a means of keeping up with family and events out of town. They work great together.

You have good points and are correct about the Aperture 3 being a significant improvement over the version 2. I agree wholly with you. I gave Aperture 3 a thumbs up and and an excellent rating. I just noted the divergence from more professional tools to more user friendly tools for the consumer. This is not a bad thing. For some reason, people feel that I am not recommending Aperture 3. I just clarify the differences in direction from other applications. This is great application especially for consumers. Actually, the market could use a good application for amateur photographers and consumers who want to go beyond just simple edits. This opens up the field for many new people to get into digital editing because of the user friendly tools.

Thank you for your comments, it is always nice to hear feedback.
Al Feb 24, 2010 3:26 PM
Missed topic
I think you really missed the interface improvements in Aperture 3. This interface is incredibly slick and intuitive compared to version two. Despite numerous changes, I simply picked it up and started playing around and after one project feel right at home in it. Some examples are the hover-over pop ups when editing in split view, and the new easy to read meta data; and there are several dozen more. Aperture has really become a great starting point in the professional and prosumer photographer's workflow, and in many cases handles all of one's needs.
Rockaway Feb 23, 2010 8:04 PM
RE: Apple Aperture 3 Review
I did like the review and didn't mean to be gruff. Sorry.

The consumer level features that debuted in iPhoto are actually quite useful, so I'm glad they made the trip to Aperture. Geotagging is future must have for all photo library management apps, and Aperture's Places feature is about as state of the art as it gets so far.

Until DSLR cameras come with GPS standard, you can use an iPhone to create a GPS track file, and Aperture will match up all the locations with your imported photos. Very cool. Then you can use all that GPS data in an Aperture book or web journal. Groundbreaking stuff that pros can charge their customers for today.
Caroline Thompson Feb 23, 2010 7:38 PM
Response to Rockaway
Hi,
You have some good points, but my review was an overall rating of the application. I agree that Aperture 3 is good editor and has lots of uses in that area, but many of the new features are more for consumer use than professional use. The exception to this (which I did note in my review with a five star rating) are the editing tools. Aperture 3 has made many new features that make editing much faster and simpler with the new version.

I don't see many bells and whistles with the slide show modules in either Lightroom or Aperture. I think it is great that they work for you and your workflow.

I gave Aperture 3 a thumbs up for new features that work well for the market they are aiming to capture. The new streamlined features make Aperture 3 an excellent choice for people who edit large groups of images and make edits without having to learn a more complex application.

Everyone has a different workflow and that is why there are so many different applications and options available. It is always wise to try everything and see if it is a good fit for your particular work flow. You make some good points and I thank you for your feedback.
Rockaway Feb 23, 2010 6:52 PM
Ap3 is for professionals
I couldn't disagree more with a couple of your ratings. First of all, Ap3 is definitely a professional tool. The printing module is second to none, and includes soft proofing, which Adobe has never included in Lightroom.

The Books feature is also a pro level tool. You can't get similar functionality from any other application. This is a HUGE timesaver for event photographers, and the output is spectacular.

Slideshows are also where Aperture shines brighter than competitors. Lightroom offers slideshows, but they are rather dull compared with Aperture's built in themes. Ap3 also lets you drop video clips into the slideshows, which is a very nice feature.

I'm not sure why you decided that Lightroom is for pros and Aperture is for less than pros, especially since Aperture now has the best RAW processing in the business.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend