GD&T Tutorial on Projected Tolerance

Written by:  • Edited by: Lamar Stonecypher
Updated Sep 7, 2010

This geometric dimensioning and tolerancing or GD&T tutorial will discuss projected tolerance and its application and benefits for preparing engineering drawings.

Engineering drawing is the communication tool among the mechanical engineers in industry. The whole intent of an engineering drawing is communicated by means of figures and suitable symbols. It is very important that the drawing conveys a single meaning to all its users and here geometric dimensioning and tolerancing, or GD&T, plays an important role. How? We will discuss this in the next paragraph.

Why to Use GD&T?

Say, you want to create a rectangular plate with a circular hole and for that created the drawing specifying the hole-centre and other dimensional details like below:

GD&T
click to enlarge

Now, with this drawing if you got a plate with a oval shaped hole with the centre at specified location, you should not be surprised as your drawing does not communicate the shape of the circle. By using GD&T in your engineering drawing, you can avoid such problems.

What is Projected Tolerance?

The projected tolerance is a GD&T modifier used for threaded and press fit holes in order to ensure the proper fitments of the mating parts by means of studs or bolts. Let’s see the following example:

Say, you have a plate with a hole in which a stud will be inserted. The projected portion of the stud will secure another mating plate. See the drawing of the bottom plate with thestud hole (top mating plate is in dotted line):

Projected Tolerance-1
click to enlarge

Now with only the positional tolerance of 0.2 specified in the drawing, the hole-axis of the bottom plate can be varied like below at the worst case:

Projected Tolerance-2
click to enlarge

From the figure it is clear that if the stud axis follows the worst case then the stud may interfere with the mating plate. And for avoiding that interference specifying the projected tolerance in the drawing is required. The below figure will show how project tolerance will avoid such interference:

Projected Tolerance-3
click to enlarge

You can see projected tolerance of 20 has been mentioned in the drawing by separate frame below the previous GD&T frame. The meaning of the projected tolerance of 20 is the positional tolerance zone of 0.2 will extend by 20mm beyond the surface of the bottom plate. And by doing so, the variation of the axis has been reduced substantially as you can see from the figure above.

Conclusion

Geometric dimensioning and tolerancing or GD&T helps create more universally interpreted engineering drawings. The projected tolerance modifier is used for the long bolts or studs that secure two mating plates.


Comments

Showing all 6 comments
 
Norm Crawford Oct 28, 2011 2:59 AM
RE: GD&T Tutorial on Projected Tolerance
It is the "projected" axis of the hole that must lie within the tolerance zone that is moved to the surface (one side or the other for a thru hole). Thus the term projected tolerance zone.
Jacques Sep 25, 2011 11:19 PM
Norman is right
when P is used, the hole itself is no longer included in the tolerance zone, only it's projection is. The reason is obvious, the stud hole position does not really matter, only the stud will influence the proper assembly
Norman Crawford Nov 1, 2010 7:33 PM
It does not Tighten the tolerance
Suvo,

The quote you are using at the end of that paragraph is a correct "quote", but I am sorry your interpretation is not. Look at Fig 6-38. The "projected" perpendicularity tolerance zone is "moved" (relocated) to above the part, not "extended". By moving the tolerance zone, the calculated tolerance value will work for the mating part "feature".
This last sentence of the paragraph is only a clarification that you can use a "projected" tolerance zone specification with orientation just as you do for location because many used to argue that projected tolerance zones can only be used with position. But effectively, it is the orientation control of position that causes the mechanical need to "move" the tolerance zone.
If all you do is "tighten" the orientation to make up for an "extended" tolerance zone, you would in effect be tightening the tolerance, resulting in higher cost.
If an orientation refinement is needed, or for some reason preferred to a projected tolerance, there is always the option ot "refine" the orientation of a feature with a second FCF, but still "tightens" the tolerance where a projected tolerance zone does not.
The bottom line is look at the figures. The figure posted here shows an "extended" zone. That is not how it is shown or intended in the standard.
See also the appendix B4 & B5.
I hope this helps and if you prefer, can contact me direct. Search in LinkedIn will find me.
Suvo Oct 28, 2010 4:35 PM
to Norman
Thank you for reading my article.

I request you to go through the paragraph 5.5 of ASME Y14.5M-1994, it says:
"......Where design considerations require a closer control in the perpendicularity of a threaded hole than that allowed by the positional tolerance, a perpendicularity tolerance applied as a projected tolerance zone may be specified.." This means projected tolerance “tighten” the tolerance.

I do agree that the symbol is as per ASME Y14.5 (1982) and not as per the latest 1994 version, but it is still used by the people.
Carly Oct 18, 2010 10:18 AM
Incorrect description
Thanks for commenting. We are looking into it.
Norman Crawford Oct 7, 2010 10:41 AM
Incorrect description of projected tolerance zone
This description of the projected tolerance zone is not correct.
The tolerance zone is not "extended". That is a common misunderstanding. The tolerance zone is "moved" to above the surface and for the stated length. Therefore, the tolerance does not "reduce" any tolerance.
Further, the Featrure control frame for stating the projected zone length is not correct. The cirlce P modifier is simply added in the tolerance block of the position (or orienation) FCF and if a blind hole, followed by the value for the length of the zone. Otherwise, a chain line with a dimension is used along with the cirlce P modifier for thru holes.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend