4. Use commas to separate nonrestrictive modifiers. Nonrestrictive modifiers are optional, meaning such modifiers can be added or deleted without changing the meaning of the main clause. For example:
- The book, which I left in my car, is from the library.
- The puppy, with the blue leash, belongs to me.
Do not use commas to separate restrictive modifiers. Restrictive modifiers are essential to the meaning of the main clause. For example:
- The book that I left in my car is from the library.
- The puppy with the blue leash belongs to me.
Nonrestrictive modifiers are distinguished from restrictive modifiers by the context of the sentence. The difference between the modifier with the blue leash in the first example and the second example is that the puppy in the second example can only be identified by the fact that he is wearing a blue leash, making the modifier necessary and restrictive. The inclusion of the modifier with the blue leash in the first example, however, is optional, additional information, and, therefore, nonrestrictive.