Netbook vs. Notebook - from Intel's Perspective

Written by:  • Edited by: Rebecca Scudder
Updated May 19, 2011
• Related Guides: Intel

Interested in a new mini-computer like a netbook? Wondering exactly what a netbook is and what you'd gain and have to give up over a notebook? We can help. At Intel Developer Forum 2008, Intel manager Mooly Eden gave us Intel's perspective on the question.

Future of Mobile Computing

On October 21, 2008 Intel Mobile Platforms Group manager Mooly Eden delivered the second day keynote address at the Intel Developer Forum in Taipei, Republic of China (Taiwan). His address was entitled “Expanding the Frontiers of Mobility.”

One of the many interesting things that Mr. Eden said was that although many industry experts predicted that 2009 will be the year that the crossover happens and more notebooks than desktop PCs are sold, 2008 is the year that Intel will sell more mobile processors than desktop processors. Part of that rapid growth in the mobile field was due to the advent of the Atom-powered mini-computers, the netbooks.

Mooly Eden also offered a look at the netbook vs. notebook question from Intel’s perspective on the past, present, and future of mobile computing.

Design Factors

Netbooks are devices designed purposely for the Internet, to communicate, learn, and view information. They have in common a compact form factor of seven to ten inches, are light-weight, feature comparatively longer battery life than notebooks, and are less dependent on a battery charger during the day. They are easily portable and can be easily moved from one place to another place. They may contain more than one wireless method to connect to the Internet. To see some examples of netbooks on the market, read about how 3 of the top netbooks compare with each another.

Notebooks are more multiple-purpose computers in a form factor of about ten inches and up. Notebooks can create content and handle heavy multi-tasking loads with many applications running at once. They can view, create, and edit high-definition video content and run intensive programs like computer aided engineering and mathematical modeling.

Differences in Mobility

Article Image
click to enlarge
Notebooks, like Netbooks, are portable, but some are becoming increasingly less so (the 17-inchers) some more so (the ultra-thins), and users of notebooks tend to pack them away in bags with all sorts of accessories before moving anywhere beyond the office or home. Although a few notebooks are able to connect to the Internet via cellular networks as well as Wi-Fi, being “locked” to a carrier is not widely considered an advantage. Thus notebook users often invest in wireless modems that are external.

Interestingly, we may see netbooks that are sold by the cellular carriers themselves as a bundle of Internet service and the device. Consumers would be likely to consider an inexpensive netbook expendable and simply stop using the wireless connection when the cellular contract was up.

So netbooks are purpose-built for a limited role, while traditional notebooks are multi-purpose general tool. (Click the image from Intel to enlarge the graphicon that explains the uses of each.)

 

What Applications Will You Run?

Article Image
click to enlarge
The central question to be asked, Mr. Eden said, was “What applications do you plan to run on it?”

If you want to run basic applications and surf the web on the go, the netbook is a good solution. However, if you want to “open five windows, if you want to run virus protection and do some indexing . . . or high definition video editing,” said Mr. Eden, then a notebook is better.

Image courtesy of Intel

Mr. Eden said that asking him which is better – the Atom (netbook) or the Core 2 Duo (notebook) processor - is like asking which child he likes best. He says that, although they are different, he likes them both. Then he said he likes all of his kids.

Other Articles About Intel Developer Forum 2008

Smoke Laminar 1
click to enlarge
Intel Promotes Laminar Cooling Tech for Laptops - Finally got that powerful laptop you've wanted for so long?
Jet Engine
click to enlarge
Surprised that the first time you heard the fan fully cut in it sounded like a jet taking off? Well, jet engines were the inspirations for Intel's new laminar flow cooling technology for laptops. Here we'll look at what they've announced.

Details Emerge about Intel Nehalem 4-Core CPU Architecture - Fresh from the Intel Developer's Forum 2008 in Taipei, Republic of China come details about the architecture, design, and performance of the forthcoming Nehalem generation of Intel CPUs. In one way, it can be summed up simply as "Quad core comes of age." Get the essential details here.

Related Reading

Netbooks, Notebooks, Laptops, and Ultra-larges - Netbook, Notebook, Laptop... What's in a name? By now, we have a pretty good idea about what the difference between a netbook and a notebook is, but is there really a difference between a laptop, a notebook, and an ultralarge? For an answer, let's look back at the beginnings of portable computing.


Comments

Showing all 12 comments
 
Dr Rupam Mitra Mar 19, 2011 11:10 AM
netbook
I want to buy a netbook in India. Please suggest which would be the best for me cost wise as well as service wise as I am an nontechnical person. I want to surf internet and want to send and receive email and want to write prose and get its print out.
From Dr Rupam Mitra, Jabalpur, India
Mluleki Nov 19, 2010 7:03 AM
Choice
I'm convinced that Notebooks are the best pcz to own.Thank you for clarity on this matter though it came late.
Ebukhosini
ANDREA Sep 5, 2010 3:55 PM
WOULD IT BE GOOD FOR COLLEGE STUDENT
would it be good for a college student, that basically types papers an surfs the net?
Roberto Feb 28, 2010 12:14 AM
Hardware choice
I want to be able to travel and make voice recordings with my goldwave software, and I'll want to take that voice recording and put it on a CD at some point. I need word processing and internet access as well. I might also want house design software on it, not CAD, something lighter, maybe Punch Home Design.

Any suggestions as to the sort of machine I need?

Thanks,
Roberto
Lamar Stonecypher Feb 27, 2010 3:18 PM
Thinking of getting a netbook...
Hi, Jamaya,

Good catch - that should have been "Republic of China" or Taiwan. I'll fix it.

Lamar
Jamaya Feb 26, 2010 4:24 PM
Thinking of getting a netbook...
I have been thinking of getting a netbook but worrying about its performance.

BTW, I think Taipei is in Taiwan not in China.

"On October 21, 2008 Intel Mobile Platforms Group manager Mooly Eden delivered the second day keynote address at the Intel Developer Forum in Taipei, China.”
Sam OBrien Jan 27, 2010 5:46 PM
Informative
I've never owned, worked on, or had much interest in a netbook, but "all-day battery life" is does entice to try one.
Lamar Stonecypher Jan 26, 2010 11:21 AM
Netbook or Notebook for College?
Hi, Ursula,

Netbooks are usually used as extensions for another PC. Thus they are great for jotting notes, all-day battery life, and syncing later to another PC. They are not the equal of a notebook in overall utility, however, because they are not that powerful and don't tend to be comfortable for long-term typing.

So my suggestion would be a netbook if she already has a more powerful PC to work with in her room -or- a notebook that can perform both roles if it's going to be her only PC.

Thanks for a good comment.
Ursula Jan 26, 2010 11:06 AM
Question??
My dughter is at University. Would this be the best tool for her? Urs from South Africa
natalia Jul 25, 2009 2:21 PM
good for taking decision
thank you very much for the article, but i'm still confused with the specs of the netbook i want to buy. which one is better, WXGA or WVGA or WSVGA? is it so far different between atom 270 and 280? if i want to give some presentation, is it ok to do it with netbook? coz i'm still not sure whether i have to buy a netbook or a 12" notebook. i've already had a 16" notebook. can you help me? thanks b4.
Nathan Hampton Jul 22, 2009 1:03 PM
Cooperation not Competition
I agree with Dwight. I have a large 17+" desktop replacement laptop (ultralarge?) that is a pain to move around and is kinda delicate. I have my netbook to go places with. The ultralarge does the "heavy lifting" then the netbook allows me to focus on doing something specific. Think of the ultralarge as a server compared to my netbook as a thin client with intermittent connectivity. The ultralarge edits the video that the netbook can play for clients. The ultralarge mixes the music that the netbook can play for others. The ultralarge does the research that (combined with the netbook's class notes) can be used to produce the report that the netbook sends in eMail at the corner coffee shop. Optical drive is on the ultralarge. USB drive ports to netbook. Wife can vid-Skype me with the ultralarge while I'm at the distant hotel with the netbook.

One key aspect of Netbooks that's been forgotten is PRICE. My ultralarge cost me $750. My netbook $300. $1,050 for TWO computers. Yet, I get more than DOUBLE the usability of a single $1K machine.
Dwight Stegall Jul 9, 2009 6:09 PM
Thank You
Thanks for this article. It helped a lot.

My opinion is it would be smart to have both. Use the Notebook for the heavy work and the Netbook when you are on the go and don't want to be burdened by a heavier computer with less battery time.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend