Microsoft Security Essentials Review: Completely Free Security Software from Microsoft

Review of Microsoft Security Essentials
by Donna Buenaventura (8,660 pts ) , published Nov 9, 2009
4

Microsoft Security Essentials is a new security solution from Microsoft, but how well does it work? Read this review to find out!

Introduction

Microsoft has been offering free anti-spyware software since 2005 following their acquisition GIANT Antispyware. The first and free antispyware by Microsoft was Windows Defender (former name is Microsoft Anti-Spyware). Microsoft is also offering Windows Live OneCare as fee-based anti-malware program, but they announced last year that it will be discontinued by the end of this month, June 30, 2009.

Microsoft Security Essentials (MSE) will replace Windows Live OneCare but will not entirely replace Windows Defender - you can either stick with Windows Defender or replace it with MSE but you should install MSE without another real-time antivirus protection. Microsoft made MSE has reach its final build and is available for public. It's no longer a beta product which means you can now take advantage of it. So, is Microsoft Security Essentials be an effective antivirus program? Some of us have seen the antivirus testing report last June by AV Comparatives. Microsoft’s anti-malware joins Kaspersky and ESET in receiving the highest certification level. However, it received standard level when AV-Comparatives run another test during August 2009 but the detection rate is 90%. That shows that MSE has the potential to be an effective antivirus program as long as Microsoft continues to add detection signatures for known and zero day malware as fast as they can.

Installation and System Requirements
Rating Excellent

Microsoft Security Essentials (MSE) can only be installed if you have Windows XP with SP2 or SP3, Vista and Windows 7 systems

Installing MSE is straightforward by accepting the EULA then validating Windows. Since the product is offering real-time anti-virus and other malware protection, you need to uninstall the other antivirus program to avoid conflict.

The program will check for updates and offer to scan the system after installation. No reboot is required so you can start configuring MSE and use the protection.

Features and Options
Rating Excellent

The key feature of MSE is to protect the system against threats using its on-access and on-demand scanner and removal. MSE will detect spyware, virus, worm, Trojans, potentially unwanted programs and other type of malware. It does not include firewall protection because Windows XP, Vista and Windows 7 have built-in firewall already.

You can opt to scan using Full, Quick or Custom scan. The program can be configured to scan removable drives (flash, USB drives) and archives. Another option in MSE is the exclusions of folder, file types, processes and drive. You can right-click a file, folder or drive for MSE to scan or use the schedule scan option in the program.

Like Windows Defender, MSE also includes Microsoft Spynet that will send to Microsoft Research Team the suspicious files or detected items that requires analysis. Allowing the program to send the files to research center will help in protecting not only your computers but all end-users of MSE and Windows Defender.

Updating Microsoft Security Essentials
Rating Average

It’s not required to turn on Automatic Updates (AU) in Windows to get the updates to MSE. You can continue to use “Notify you for updates” in AU. If you prefer to turn off AU, you should configure MSE to run a scheduled scan (quick scanning for example) and choose to check for updates before the scan. This means if you have daily scheduled scan, you have scheduled too the daily checking and download of detection updates for MSE.

The Update tab has “update” button that will connect to Microsoft Update servers. Other method is to update isby downloading the daily updates from Microsoft website. You can also download the update via Windows Update website. Watch the Microsoft Malware Protection Portal pages also for links in downloading the definitions for MSE or MSAM: Microsoft Malware Protection Portal

Performance and Effectiveness
Rating Good

MSE is light to use while you are scanning or when the product is running. I run a test for the detection capability of MSE: Out of 201 samples, MSE detected 153 items. Not bad detection by MSE - the excellent NOD32 detected only a handful more items (165).

Price to Value
Rating Excellent

It's free and effective. What more can I say?

Conclusion

Microsoft Security Essentials is light-weight and has good detection capabilities. Highly recommended.

Images

User Interface of MSEAlerts by MSEReal-time Protection's Threat AlertVirtual Memory Usage

Comments

Nov 8, 2009 2:38 AM
Missed "out"
Right Tom, I missed the word "without". Thanks for pointing that out :-)

Regards,
Donna
Nov 8, 2009 2:31 AM
Tom
Conflicting Info
You state in the beginning you should use MSE with another AV program, but then in the installation and System Requirements section you state that you should uninstall other AV programs before installing MSE.
Jun 22, 2009 1:00 PM
MSE Video and Comment
Here is a video of MSE: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dfr4THSV90o

Anyway, I don't like MSE because it is just a signature-based security program.
 
Subscribe to Computer Security
RSS
Get free weekly updates, directly to your inbox.
Browse Computer Security