McAfee SiteAdvisor Review

Written by:  • Edited by: Bill Bunter
Updated May 5, 2010
• Related Guides: Reviews | Web Browser | Search Results
4

In an attempt to offer safer web browsing, this web browser add-on gives users a bit of peace of mind when exploring different websites, going through search results, and even downloading documents. Does it really offer protection, or is it just a false sense of security?

About

McAfee
click to enlarge
There are many different available websites on the internet today. Some of them are useful, where some of them can potentially harm your computer. SiteAdvisor indicates the validity of a website depending on the colour of its icon. It attaches itself either on the bottom of your browser window, or near the address bar depending on which web browser you’re using.

Installation
Rating Good

Since it’s an add-on, the file size of the installer is not terribly big, nor does it take a long time to install. Within minutes, or seconds depending on your internet connection speed, the product will have successfully installed on your computer.

Interface & User Friendliness
Rating Average

As mentioned before, the add-on attaches itself to your browsing window. Whenever you want to review information about a website, or search results, simply click on the icon to be taken to a different web page. You’ll see a summary of what most people say about the site, any potential risks, amongst other components that a web page might attempt in order for you to download some unwanted information.

If you’re a webmaster, or a regular web user, you can register so you can leave comments about a website. You can comment why you like it or don’t like it.

Effectiveness
Rating Average

Site Review
click to enlarge
While SiteAdvisor is efficient at noting which websites and search results have been fully tested or not, this may have a tendency of leaning some users into a false sense of security, or worse, a false sense of panic. SiteAdvisor’s results come from user reviews, and some users are inclined to write some reviews because they either had a bad personal experience at the website, or just couldn’t quite figure it out. In that case, they write reviews on why they don’t like that particular website which could be completely irrelevant to a website’s credibility. So at this point, the only obvious safes versus unsafe websites can be noticed, whereas suspicious websites can still remain up in the air – all without help of the SiteAdvisor add-on. Nonetheless, if you’re a curious web surfer who is interested in what other people have to say about some of your websites, you can find some useful (or useless) reviews.

Some websites may even be able to trick SiteAdvisor’s scanners, making them seem like a legitimate website. In which case, the add-on isn’t effective in the least, as common sense would have to be your main ally when surfing or downloading from a certain site.

Overall
Rating Average

It’s difficult to complain too much about SiteAdvisor, as it is a free add-on to your web browser. Those who have the McAfee Antivirus Suite will even have this add-on as part of that package. So while it does still leave some scepticism in regards to its accuracy, it can still be used as a tool to help you decide which websites to visit and which to avoid. Because of the ways some websites can trick the scanner, it doesn’t mean that with this add-on you’ll have complete peace of mind. This doesn’t necessarily mean that the add-on doesn’t help at all. You can read user reviews of a website; if you’re a webmaster, you can leave some comments about your own site, not to mention reviewing other websites. So while this add-on doesn’t fully shield you from the evils of the internet, it can still help you decide where to go.

More Reviews!

Would you like to read more reviews? Look around Bright Hub and you’ll find reviews of numerous other leading security solutions including McAfee Total Protection, SpamTitan, GFI MailEssentials, Atek Secure Password Organizer, GFI LANguard, Norton Internet Security, Kaspersky Internet Security, ESET Smart Security, Norman Internet Security Suite and Undelete.


Comments

Showing all 2 comments
 
Joe Beanfish Feb 16, 2011 10:46 AM
Random ratings
Siteadvisor is terrible. It's ratings are pretty much random. Sites that don't change suddenly go from green to red. DNS aliases of green sites are marked as red.

Completely unreliable and misleading.
66. Tina Jul 3, 2009 9:18 PM
McAfee doesn't update results soon enough!
I searched towels in Google. First result page was Turkishtowels.com . The site was green ticked with McAfee, but there was a warning by Google "This site may harm your computer."

According to McAfee it was safe! I clicked on the Google information link and copied the data below. Turkishtowels.com was not safe for Google but according to McAfee it was safe!

What happened when Google visited Turkishtowels.com site?

Of the 11 pages we tested on the site over the past 90 days, 6 page(s) resulted in malicious software being downloaded and installed without user consent. The last time Google visited this site was on 2009-07-03, and the last time suspicious content was found on this site was on 2009-07-03.

Malicious software includes 10 trojan(s), 9 scripting exploit(s), 7 exploit(s). Successful infection resulted in an average of 1 new process(es) on the target machine.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend