Beware of Magazine Sales and Subscription Scams

Written by:  • Edited by: Bill Bunter
Updated Feb 5, 2012
• Related Guides: New York Times | Google

If that young person at your door gives you some long emotional story before they even tell you what they are selling, then chances are they are involved in a scam. The sad thing is that they might not even know it.

A knock on the door...

This past weekend, I had some friends over when someone rang my doorbell. I looked through my peephole and thought the guy on my porch as another friend of mine who was supposed to be out of town. When I opened the door, I realized that my friend was still out of town, and the guy on my porch was there to sell me something. For the record, I have never and will never buy anything from anyone who knocks on my door.

The first thing the guy said to me was, “Your neighbors said you were friendly. Are you friendly?” I am pretty friendly, but I hope my neighbors didn’t get this guy’s hopes up by telling him that. He then hands me this beat up old card that has a bunch of handwritten notes like ‘I Win!’ and other junk on it. This guy, who was probably about 20 years old, then mentions the name of some program he is in that is supposed to help him better his public relation skills and something else. I wasn’t really paying that much attention.

He went through this long spiel about how he needed 20,000 points to earn a trip to somewhere and how he was in first place with 19,000 and needed just a few more to get the trip. What it eventually got around to was the guy was trying to sell me some overpriced magazines. I politely declined and the fake smile on his face quickly went away. He made some comment that I think was hopefully polite, but I was already closing the door when he said it.

Back in August 2005, the Washington Post did a story on Magazine Sales Scams where people claimed to be from a school or some group, but were not. Even the FTC (Federal Trade Commission) website warns about magazine subscription scams. A Google search for ‘magazine sales scams’ returns hundreds of articles from newspaper and television websites all over the United States that report related scams in their area.

Scam details...

While not all door-to-door magazine sales are a scam, many of them are. Often times, it is the people doing the selling who are as much a victim of the scam as those people who actually buy the magazines. The sad part of it is that the guy at my door might be an unsuspecting participant in the scam. He might really think he’s going to get a prize trip somewhere. I am pretty sure he was lying about the 19,000 points and how he was in first place, because it made for a juicy sales pitch. It was like he was trying to make me feel sorry enough for him to want to buy a magazine. Homey don’t play that.

I did some research on the subject, and uncovered another problem related to the magazine sales. The unscrupulous companies who put these kids out on the street to go door-to-door often work the sellers like indentured servants. Many of them are loaded up on a bus and taken to distant areas where they are pretty much forced to work all day and most wind up making very little money. It is promises of prizes like trips that entice these young people into signing up for the work, but the majority of them end up with very little to show for their effort.

In February 2001, the New York Times ran a horrifying four-page story about young people caught up in magazine sales crews and the kind of things they went through. Check it out and you may think twice about even opening the door to these people. In fact, I wish now that I had warned that young man at my door of what he was involved in, and to get out as soon as he could. If these people show up at your home or business, don’t fall for any of their sob stories. A legitimate salesperson wouldn’t need to get into such a long story before they even told you what they were selling.


Comments

Showing all 10 comments
 
john Woodford Jul 13, 2011 6:08 PM
magazine door-to-door sales scams
Watch out for ay identifying themselves as Successful Achievers representing the makeithappenteam. I ordered a sub from them in Oct 2010 and it never came. They have a Warren, Mich., address but never answer their phone (though it is usually kept on busy!)
Sara Oct 18, 2010 1:28 PM
Not all companies are scams
I actually worked for one of these companies and went door to door myself for a little over three years. Not all of these companies are scams, but its best to be careful. Make sure the person at your door doesn't say its for school or they are from the area. I won the contest and was sent to St. Thomas, Virgin Islands for a week long all inclusive vacation!! And I also won some money. These are commission based jobs as well as a contest. Top sales agent wins the trip basically. Just be careful and if you don't trust someone at your door don't open it. It can be just as scary for the person going door to door. I'm sorry for people that have been ripped off by scam crews in the past, but please don't think everyone is a scam.
Jason Apr 28, 2010 10:05 AM
I encountered this back in 1997
Many years back, I came across this very thing. It was a Saturday afternoon, summer 1997. I was at my local shopping mall, when a young girl approached me. She was talking fast and she hooked her arm into mine and said the same song and dance I've read on here about winning that trip to some far away, fun place. And of course I could help her out by buying some over priced magazines. I balked at first, but, then she changed gears, and that softened me up. I was 23, (about to turn 24) back then, and she said she was 21. She looked every bit of 21, so I didn't doubt that. We got to chatting it up for awhile and seemed to really relate to each other. Then, the thing that pulled me in, hook, line, and sinker was when she played on my biggest weakness. Hooking up, if you will. She offered up her phone number. It was to her pager (this was 1997, no cell phones, blackberries, iphones, twitter, facebook, etc). It was not uncommon in the 1990's for people to stay in touch via pagers, especially in the world of singles/dating. I asked her to walk with me as I went to a pay phone (damn, I feel old being able to recall those!) and called the number she had given me. It worked. So, I bought some magazines. The thing is, I did get the magazines, I just paid a lot for them, like a dummy. And, my phone rang off the hook with high pressure sales calls for other magazines and offers. And her pager number was disconnected soon thereafter. Go figure. The money was really not an issue. They only took me for like $65.00. To me, it was the issue of me ending up looking like a damn fool when I tried calling her on that pager that worked fine the day she gave it to me, and never again after that. Looking back, my favorite line from her was when she extended her hand, and I shook it, and she said "sorry, now I have to charge you a handling fee". Corny! Oh well, live and learn.
Lyn Mar 11, 2010 9:54 PM
Magazine Scam
I believe this is who came to my door today. The same story about being a "communications" major. He was in a contest to try and beat the girls to see how many points he could get. He was very friendly and outgoing. He tried to convince me to write a check. As soon as I declined his attitude changed and made me very uncomfortable. Please do not open the door if you don't know who it is! Don't fall for this scam! He told me I was the only one in the neighborhood who wouldn't help him out. He was such a smooth talker, I almost fell for it.
Bill Fulks Jan 7, 2010 11:53 AM
For Scott
Scott, why don't you send me your home address and I'll have them come over? Are you serious? I'm not going to let some stranger into my home. Yeah, it might could help them, but the risk isn't worth it.
Bill Fulks Jan 7, 2010 11:51 AM
Looks like they are at it again
Last weekend, one of these people knocked on my door again. I wasn't home, but my wife answered. My boss just told me he had three in the past month, and one even claimed to be a college student working on a 'communications' degree.
Scott Jan 7, 2010 10:55 AM
These people are an opportunity
"Check it out and you may think twice about even opening the door to these people. In fact, I wish now that I had warned that young man at my door of what he was involved in, and to get out as soon as he could."
You contradict yourself here. The truth is if you are smart enough to recognize that this child may be caught up in a scam, then you shoudl have politely invited him in and told him this information. The reason why "horrifying 4-page stor[ies]" exist is because of heartless people who do not try to affect other's lives. The whole "how dare this person interrupt my party" attitude is very sad. This kid could this day still be trying to sell this stuff and hasn't made a dime but has wasted many hours and money because he hasn't had parents or anyone teach him better.

So in the future, if some sob story comes to your door begging for money (whether it is a scam or legit) invite them in for a cup of coffee or hot chocolate or glass of water. Be friendly and you just might affect someone's life for the better!
Andrew Jan 6, 2010 11:17 PM
Same thing for me
I was outside Wal Mart when a young girl told me an almost identical story, that she needed to talk to a nice person, was in public speaking class, and was trying to win a trip to Germany and was in first place with 19,000 points. Talked to me for close to a half hour I would say, and eventually I just said I didn't want any of the magazine subscriptions, and the smile on her face was immediately gone and she stormed away. I recently saw these crooks inside the same Wal Mart soliciting to shoppers, so I told the employees about it and they were kind of surprised but will hopefully get rid of them.
Abigail Walker Aug 6, 2009 6:15 PM
RE: Beware of Magazine Sales and Subscription Scams
Same exact thing just happened to me mere minutes ago! I was approached by a young, tattooed guy in the parking lot of a major dept. store (that doesn't allow that sort of thing in front of their stores). He complemented me profusely, and tried (emphasis on that one) to make me laugh. After giving me his big spiel/sob story, I politely declined.(he talked so fast I didn't really understand, anyway) Well, his attitude completely changed, and I called him out on it; I ended up just walking away.

What kind of person approaches a women by herself in a parking lot, anyway?
Margaret Jul 7, 2009 12:25 AM
Mag Sub Sales Scams
Yep, I just realized (five months after the fact) that I was indeed ripped off by a magazine subscription salesman. Unfortunately, the only thing I could do about it was blog a humorous cautionary tale about it: http://www.nannygoatsinpanties.com/2009/07/universal-subscription-services-inc.html. In that post, I included a link I another article which is written by a former employee who exposes the company he worked for.

- Margaret
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend