Part 2: Do You Need a Third-Party Firewall with Windows 7?

Written by:  • Edited by: Bill Bunter
Updated Jun 26, 2011
• Related Guides: Windows 7 | Firewall | Windows Firewall

In second part of this series, we will discuss whether a third party firewall is needed instead of using the built-in firewall in Windows 7

Third Party Firewall for Windows 7?

Firewall software
click to enlarge
This type of topic is often discussed in several security forums, newsgroup or mailing lists. It is also covered many times by several security analysts, researchers and technology writers. However, it is always a question by many of us if third-party firewall software is best to use instead of the free and built-in, Windows Firewall. It’s also good to discuss this type of topic again since the firewall software in Windows has new features and this might change how other people believe that the Windows 7’s Firewall program is lacking features that third-party firewall software has.

By looking at the controls in managing Windows Firewall in Windows 7, no doubt that it is easy as 1-2-3 to handle but for most people, the Advanced Security option in Windows Firewall is something they will not even touch unless they are familiar with it already.

The Windows Firewall with Advanced Security Control Panel is actually very powerful but messing up with its settings or firewall rules might put you at risk so it’s best to modify the settings if you know what you are doing. Unlike third party firewall software, the Windows Firewall will not prompt which network do you trust, and which applications do you allow even if you have configured it to notify you if it allowed or blocked a program to access the internet. For example, after I installed Windows 7 and alternative browser, Windows Firewall did not ask me whether I want Opera browser to connect to the internet. Also, Windows Firewall will automatically create firewall rules on features or applications that it trusts. Example: Windows Media Player, Office Programs or other features in Windows that requires connection.

The above can be modified by every person so nothing is allowed to make a connection unless you have explicitly allows it by creating your own firewall rules. With Windows Firewall in Windows 7, you are still in control but you need to adjust it which is similar to using third party firewall. The difference is the third party firewall is easily manageable during and after installation, you'll receive prompts on every connection attempts by an application or remote computer and it will display which port or protocol is triggered by an application. With Windows Firewall, some people have no idea which features in Windows or programs has the ability to make a connection to another network unless they will review the list of firewall rules and applications that have permission to make incoming and outgoing connections.

Windows 7 Firewall has excellent controls but...

The features and options in Windows 7 are good enough for people to use. However, Firewall software is not only about network controls, user interface (UI) and manageability alone but it should have the ability to protect you from malicious attackers so your computer will not become computer zombie, open to intruders, vulnerable to exploits and can shield the connection or PC from port scanning. Also see the other article: Windows Firewall: Is It Good Enough?

Reference

  • Image credit: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/10/Firewall_bw.png by DBGthekafu [GPL (www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons.
  • Information based on author's experience and research.

Comments

Showing all 4 comments
 
Mml813 Oct 28, 2011 1:36 PM
RE: Part 2: Do You Need a Third-Party Firewall with Windows 7?
This article doesn't answer the question whether the Windows 7 firewall is enough or not.
Donna Buenaventura Jun 25, 2011 1:08 AM
RE: Part 2: Do You Need a Third-Party Firewall with Windows 7?
Hello,

Thanks for the comments.

Sorry if you find the article poorly written. I have updated the article :)
The article is a series based on topic title (from overview, how to use the Windows Firewall and whether people should use third-party firewall).

Regards,
Donna
Lou Jun 15, 2011 2:22 AM
waste of time
This article was poorly written and lacked content.
Ngauthammasan Phanlop Jan 20, 2010 9:35 AM
When we create rules... how can we know that it work or not ?
In Windows XP there are comments to close port 137,138,139 (Netbios) and 445 (Microsoft-ds) when not used it.
When I close these port by using created rules in Windows 7 and I used program currports, this program still show these ports (137.138.139 and 445 ) that make understand these ports still open, And I also disable netbios in network connections (local area connecction, wireless network connection, 1394 connection)
(all of these port never show in currport when we close in Windows XP
But when I use regedit to closed port 445 (microsoft-ds) (as comments in Windows XP) in Windows 7. After I use currport I found port 137,138,139 not show any more (it seem that these ports are close) but port 445 still show but only listening.
So I wonder that when I use create firewall rules in Windows 7. Why these ports still show when I used currport.
And when I use regedit in windows 7 to close port 445 (the same way as Windows XP), Why port 137 ,138, 139 were closed (not show when use currport) but port 445 (microsoft-ds) still open (show) but listening stage.
 
blog comments powered by Disqus
Email to a friend